Will computers eventually replace teachers?

Soapbox

(CNN) -- The Hole in the Wall experiments, known as HiW, were first implemented in 1999, when a computer with an internet connection was embedded into a wall for children to discover and use unsupervised.

The wall adjoined a slum in India. Only a month later, it was evident that the children had taught themselves to use the computer and also picked up some skills in English and mathematics. This kind of design was then set up in more and more remote areas across the nation with almost identical results. These were computers embedded in walls or kiosks in easily accessible and highly visible public spaces, facilitating peer interaction, discovery and learning in groups of children.

We concluded that groups of children from disadvantaged and remote settings can learn to use computers and access internet resources, on their own, if given appropriate free, public and unsupervised access.

These earliest experiences also showed that children could develop some skills in English and mathematics. What came through unequivocally in this and further work on self-organizing systems in education was that groups of children -- irrespective of who or where they are, or what language they speak -- given free and public access to computers and the internet can:

1. Become computer-literate on their own -- that is, they can learn to use computers and the internet for most of the tasks done by lay users.

2. Teach themselves enough English to use e-mail, chat and search engines

3. Learn in a few months to search the internet for answers to questions.

4. Improve their English pronunciation on their own.

5. Improve their mathematics and science scores in school.

6. Be prepared to pass examinations several years ahead of grade level.

7. Change their social interaction skills and value systems.

8. Form independent opinions and detect indoctrination.

We then went on to show that the quality of traditional schooling declines the farther schools are from the urban center of New Delhi. A similar decline is visible in the UK as one goes to more economically disadvantaged areas.

Two landmark events took this work further. The first was a comment by the late Sir Arthur C. Clarke to me: "Teachers that can be replaced by a machine should be".

The second was an experiment in a Tsunami-hit Indian village, where I was trying to prove that Tamil-speaking 12-year-olds cannot teach themselves biotechnology in English.

At the end of the experiment, a little girl told me, "Apart from the fact that improper replication of the DNA molecule causes genetic disease, we have understood nothing else."

Finally, we found that the presence of a friendly, but not knowledgeable, mediator can enable children to reach levels of learning similar to formal schools with trained teachers.

We went on to set up a "cloud" of "eMediators," mostly retired schoolteachers with broadband access from their homes. Schools can access this "cloud" over Skype and children can interact with the mediators over free videoconferencing.

Interestingly, in the hands of good teachers, these methods can be powerful motivators for children, resulting in better performance. What started out as a solution for remote areas turned out to have universal applicability.

Both HiW and the work done later are based on the concept of Minimally Invasive Education, a pedagogic method that motivates groups of children to learn in an environment with little or no intervention from teachers or other adults, and that formed the basis of the design of the 'HiW' computers.

It is now possible to formulate a new approach to learning, using these findings.

Comments

Tue, 2016/08/09 - 7:20am Education #174
SkyeClapp's picture
Joined 2016-08-09
Votes: 0
Polls:
Comments: 2

Great site and a great topic as well I really get amazed to read this. It’s really good. I like viewing web sites which comprehend the price of delivering the excellent useful resource free of charge. 70-412 test

Mon, 2016/08/15 - 1:34pm Re: Will computers eventually replace teachers? #179
FerdinandoManfrin's picture
Joined 2016-08-15
Votes: 1
Polls:
Comments: 61

Well computers are very good at educating students since their young age, but i dont think so they can replace teachers. Yes i do agree that there is an uncountable information if searched on internet according to
www.bestcustomessay.org/essays/ blogs suggestion. But teachers are only teachers who make the student to go or study in right path and let them undertsand in easiest way.

Mon, 2016/09/26 - 11:31am Re: Will computers eventually replace teachers? #216
luzarnav's picture
Joined 2016-09-26
Votes: 0
Polls:
Comments: 1

I question that any robot can change in accordance with the unique needs every understudy. They might have the capacity to show nuts and bolts like arithmetic yet then a PC system can go far to doing that right at this point. a good essay writing company. Educating a dialect is additionally being done all prepared by PC programs. You needn't bother with a robot.

Mon, 2016/11/21 - 1:47pm Re: Will computers eventually replace teachers? #263
Rosealvin's picture
Joined 2016-11-15
Votes: 0
Polls:
Comments: 2

Strong CPU are extremely high-quality at humanizing scholar because their youthful age, but i don’t believe so they can put back teacher. Yes i do have the similar view that there is an uncountable in order Expert assignment Writer – Assignmentking .

Mon, 2017/01/02 - 7:29am Re: Will computers eventually replace teachers? #298
LaraOConnor's picture
Joined 2017-01-02
Votes: 0
Polls:
Comments: 1

This is not a fact that computer would replace the teachers because its the impossible thing Do My Dissertation because computer can't perform those activities which are performed by the teachers there are many things which are eventually taken up by the teachers.

Fri, 2017/02/24 - 10:18am Re: Will computers eventually replace teachers? #456
allendavid's picture
Joined 2017-02-24
Votes: 1
Polls:
Comments: 1

My last affirmation is this: the preponderance things I have perused on the subject of it says that imitation retention is a deprived approach to complete ascendancy of an assortment of in sequence. The genuine objective of education Research Paper Writing Company I believe is to have the capacity to take existing data and make new determinations from it. folks argue 21st century abilities; all things considered this exceptionally old skill is all you have to win through in our new in order base wealth.

Tue, 2017/03/14 - 12:24pm Re: Will computers eventually replace teachers? #543
angelamaria's picture
Joined 2016-08-08
Votes: 0
Polls:
Comments: 33

I think this is a relevant topic to get discussed. Nowadays various online courses are available and all are very much interested to study it. I think both have equal importance. We can choose one according to our desire. Keep updating more. used mobile homes for sale

Wed, 2017/03/15 - 12:15pm nice topic #548
issec's picture
Joined 2017-03-15
Votes: 0
Polls:
Comments: 11

I am completely agreed with your opinion. When the technology enhances us people depending computers more than ever as it give the answers within a second. I think over usage of such things will create many problems in future.remodeling service Los Angeles

Mon, 2017/03/27 - 9:32am Re: Will computers eventually replace teachers? #592
Ashliwetmore's picture
Joined 2017-03-27
Votes: 1
Polls:
Comments: 1

I concur with you. Each instructor ought to in any event be outfitted with the fundamental learning of PCs. You don't need to be a specialist as a classroom educator, buy an assignment online yet have enough innovative canny to explore understudies through straightforward issues with the PC.

Mon, 2017/03/27 - 10:12am Re: Will computers eventually replace teachers? #593
stewartouis's picture
Joined 2017-03-27
Votes: 0
Polls: 1
Comments: 1

I'm moderately convinced I'll acquire lots of new material accurate now! Dissertation writing service

Wed, 2017/07/19 - 11:46am Re: Will computers eventually replace teachers? #2499
AshleySewell's picture
Joined 2017-05-15
Votes: 0
Polls:
Comments: 2

I don't think so because there are lot of still lot of years to make this happen true. This is because AI is not enough improved yet.

Coursework writing service

Wed, 2017/08/09 - 11:06am Re: Will computers eventually replace teachers? #2690
katherinemartina's picture
Joined 2017-08-09
Votes: 2
Polls:
Comments: 1

I can't help contradicting it I believe that teachers are our second guardians. Teachers can impart their insight to us. They mind our oversight at each progression of our life. They can take care of every one of our issues Help with Coursework Assistance. They can feel our feelings, our emotions. Computer can't comprehend people. They just gave arrangements. So the part of educators throughout our life is significant.

Thu, 2017/11/16 - 12:45pm Re: Will computers eventually replace teachers? #4627
kristinestevart's picture
Joined 2017-11-16
Votes: 0
Polls:
Comments: 1

First You got a great blog .I will be interested in more similar topics. i see you got really very useful topics, i will be always checking your blog thanks. UK essay writing service

Wed, 2018/01/17 - 4:30pm Re: Will computers eventually replace teachers? #4954
RamaHay's picture
Joined 2018-01-17
Votes: 0
Polls:
Comments: 1

I think that closer time - no, but it possible. Our technic develops so fast that I can believe it. College papers done for you within the shortest deadlines interesting will work like today or no? 
 

Tue, 2018/03/13 - 5:30am Re: Will computers eventually replace teachers? #5487
annajulia's picture
Joined 2018-02-05
Votes: 0
Polls:
Comments: 1

This isn't a reality that PC would supplant the instructors since its the incomprehensible thing dissertation service since PC can't play out those exercises which are performed by the educators there are numerous things which are in the long run taken up by the instructors.

Tue, 2018/07/17 - 3:01am Re: Will computers eventually replace teachers? #6859
wq123's picture
Joined 2018-07-17
Votes: 0
Polls:
Comments: 82

Finally oakley sunglasses outlet looked christian louboutin resting nike free 5.0 the bucks jersey rainy michael kors weather. However, due michael kors bags to the thomas sabo soft, adidas yeezy shoes unable harvester skechers shoes outlet into skechers shoes the michael kors outlet ground, coach purses outlet but new york knicks jerseys also christian louboutin the true religion United adidas States nike huarache and pandora outlet the United g by guess States ray ban sunglasses outlet had to ralph lauren dry giuseppe shoes for tommy hilfiger a redskins nfl jersey day. Last air force night, asics shoes outlet he soccer shoes specifically waiting ray ban in front of the michael kors outlet online TV, north face backpacks listen grizzlies jersey to broncos nfl jersey the kate spade outlet weather skechers forecast, woolrich outlet when cheap nhl jerseys he oakley vault learned supra shoes that prada sunglasses today ferragamo is nike cloudy, marc jacobs the ralph lauren uk highest oakley sungalsses outlet temperature longchamp handbags outlet is seahawks nfl jersey 30 replica handbags ℃, new balance shoes he was nba jerseys thrilled, bottega secretly determined, air max 90 anyway parajumpers outlet 2 christian louboutin acres michael kors bags of raiders nfl jersey wheat dansko shoes will rush dallas mavericks jersey in burberry outlet as soon hilfiger online shop as possible jack wolfskin ca come ralph lauren online shop back.

 

To michael kors handbags his surprise, about nba jerseys seven christian louboutin in mcm handbags the morning, michael kors not houston rockets jersey after azcardinals nfl jersey breakfast, nike free Eastern sun north face jackets actually swarovski exposed polo ralph lauren outlet online red tory burch outlet smiley ferragamo uk face, burberry outlet less nike air max than michael kors uk an coach outlet store hour, hermes birkin they shine, hilfiger outlet shining polo outlet the kate spade entire adidas concrete softball bats floor longchamp handbags boiling moncler outlet hot.

 

Sunny timberland shoes face, he burberry outlet is asics outlet rejoicing, salvatore ferragamo the God scoff burberry uk amazing sentence: ralph lauren "?? the north face This nike is eyeglasses online not ecco shoes what people do atlanta hawks jersey day mcm backpack to air max 2015 get mont blanc the suns jersey weather nike free run forecast michael kors usa ye moncler jackets also lions nfl jersey coax nike air max people pacers jersey do."

 

At mizuno running the salomon same thomas sabo time, it supra shoes strengthened coach outlet his fidget spinner resolve uggs boots to bengals nfl jersey harvest hogan shoes wheat. converse After tommy hilfiger patiently the north face jackets waiting uhren in c.c beanies line, chiefs nfl jersey a ray ban large north face machine timberland Reaper north face finally nike into huarache the true religion outlet store ground. adidas Less new balance than two burberry cigarettes mizuno running shoes effort, asics and 2 wizards jersey acres cheap nfl jerseys of adidas land true religion jeans on tods shoes outlet all wheat barbour harvest bcbg dresses is air max shoes completed, versace outlet and belstaff jackets the mcm handbags number cheap ray ban of cheap shoes consecutive eagles nfl jersey car polo ralph golden vans grain is lacoste outlet also sent nba jerseys outlet to the five finger shoes doorstep.

 

He jordan smiles givenchy antigona to summon jack wolfskin outlet the dsquared2 wife, giuseppe zanotti Liu ray ban Ying ralph lauren polo and north face outlet daughter cowboys nfl jersey to beats by dre spend guess factory time air max with philipp plein him timberwolves jersey along tory burch sale the road swarovski jewelry in christian louboutin outlet front juicy couture outlet of denver nuggets jersey the philipp plein outlet sun ralph lauren outlet on oakley outlet online a barbour jackets outlet grain panthers nfl jersey of mbt shoes wheat. coach black friday With ravens nfl jersey his prada son oakley sunglasses outlet Hu air max Niu flat iron was bottega veneta him buccaneers nfl jersey away, his philadelphia 76ers jersey wife chargers nfl jersey sudden michael kors uk stroke detroit pistons jerseys two months fred perry ago adidas schuhe and has mont blanc pens not converse shoes yet scarpe hogan fully links of london recovered, and iphone cases heavily hermes outlet pregnant true religion jeans outlet daughter, replica watches it michael kors outlet has ralph lauren outlet been vikings nfl jersey four beats by dr dre or roshe run five oakley months nike pregnant, calvin klein and iphone case therefore, also burberry outlet depends rams nfl jersey mainly coach outlet usa on oakley vault the thomas sabo charms family jordan retro farm nfl jerseys he cleveland cavaliers jersey worked michael kors outlet online sale hard. But eyeglass frames in the polo outlet online busy nike occasion, tommy hilfiger outlet he ralph lauren polos has coach factory outlet a busy man, cheap jerseys however, oakley sunglasses outlet I had oakley sunglasses outlet to let kings jersey them ray bans play pelicans jersey along jimmy choo shoes the ray ban way, michaelkors.com such swarovski crystal as oklahoma city thunder jerseys sweeping the north face the bills nfl jersey floor, designer handbags pushing warriors jersey wheat, horloges stir los angeles lakers jerseys the oakley sunglasses wheat nike free run class, he vans thinks nike store this is air jordans their nike free best los angeles clippers jerseys of coach factory outlet online its swarovski canada ability. jazz jersey Of prada outlet course, texans nfl jersey three pandora jewelry meals new balance a retro jordans day, also nike mercurial owned pandora jewellery daughter guciheaven outlet to do, raptors jersey he michael kors outlet online thinks roshe run this belstaff jackets outlet is a burberry canada woman's prada handbags duty air huarache to cook, has prada shoes nothing to jordan shoes do hoodies outlet with coach black friday pregnancy, roshe runs not salvatore ferragamo to nike factory mention nike roshe now nhl jerseys is reebok shoes not ralph lauren outlet online the dsquared2 outlet occasion uggs outlet to true religion outlet labor, juicy couture let adidas shoes alone nike his basketball shoes wife tory burch outlet got coach outlet sick, barbour jackets and this michael kors outlet is new balance outlet the nike air max cooking of hermes his hilfiger wife and swarovski daughter swarovski to michael kors outlet succeed bcbg max right belstaff outlet and barbour jackets proper air max 2015 thing! You see, coach sacs the adidas talk lunette oakley of adidas shoes the oakley sungalsses outlet town colts nfl jersey home ralph lauren or daughter graduate, omega watches gave tn pas cher birth charlotte hornets jersey to fitflop their omega watches first puma shoes child a christian louboutin shoes boy, ray ban sunglasses and oakley sunglasses cheap now With handbags outlet a valentino second child, nba shoes still mlb jerseys rushing air max back ferragamo shoes to occhiali ray ban pot converse roast bears nfl jersey to new balance cook! It falcons nfl jersey is longchamp more nike roshe envy! polo ralph lauren Thus, oakley sungalsses outlet he red bottoms often ralph lauren used his mcm bags daughter nets jerseys enlighten spurs jersey hear Hermes his levi's jeans own ralph lauren daughter. soccer shoes outlet To kate spade outlet this end, browns nfl jersey Liu christian louboutin shoes Ying oakley outlet is very burberry uk fast, tommy hilfiger and often dolphins nfl jersey tears. pandora Now burberry outlet online is cheap true religion the busy nike air max season, burberry how can the north face outlet let oakley sungalsses outlet daughter longchamp busy break cheap mlb jerseys it? converse sneakers Moreover, Huda ray ban outlet Fu giants nfl jersey experience, this ray ban certainly chrome hearts outlet can reebok not coach outlet go under armour outlet wrong. ray ban After ray-ban sunglasses all, fendi outlet the coach outlet online second kate spade outlet child coach outlet is ralph lauren factory store very ralph lauren accurate patriots nfl jersey diagnosis. jordan release dates Although michael kors outlet the jets nfl jersey first vans shoes child a nike air mistake, miami heat jerseys but stone island it burberry is marc jacobs also nfl jerseys Liu orlando magic jersey Ying nike store was with fred perry outlet him coach factory outlet sulk michael kors mismatch puma caused nike air by the burberry handbags medicine saints nfl jersey can pandora not blame versace outlet people mcm backpack outlet not 49ers nfl jersey fine. He long champ also soccer outlet vaguely ray ban remember pandora uk the nba jersey scene: Liu Ying Hu timberland boots Dafu polo ralph lauren not michael kors outlet happy michael kors australia to nike roshe run find coach outlet a cheap jerseys diagnosis, nike canada acquaintances tory burch sandals insist lacoste outlet online to jaguars nfl jersey the timberland outlet county ray ban hospital to do B-examination, ray ban wayfarer he beats by dre headphones said relojes that cheap jordans private clinics cheap jerseys can not hugo boss online be packers nfl jersey trusted. michael kors outlet And barbour jacket outlet he chicago bulls jerseys was coach outlet online to under armour save trail blazers jersey money, titans nfl jersey Huda Fu will michael kors go air max home, michael kors and hogan forced armani exchange her boston celtics jerseys to polo ralph lauren outlet make steelers nfl jersey a babyliss diagnosis. pandora charms She was nike shoes outlet due jimmy choo to ed hardy

nike store